2/21 – International News Update & Economic Analysis
As Germany approaches a pivotal general election, Friedrich Merz, the conservative frontrunner and likely next chancellor, has voiced grave concerns about the European Union’s financial stability. He warns that unsustainable public debt across several member states could soon trigger another financial crisis. His remarks reflect mounting apprehension over Europe’s economic direction, particularly as Germany struggles with stagnation and increasing fiscal pressures.
Merz has emphasized that excessive government borrowing poses a fundamental risk to economic stability. While he refrained from naming specific countries, it is well-documented that France, Italy, Greece, Belgium, Spain, and Portugal have accumulated debt exceeding their annual economic output. According to Merz, a sovereign debt crisis is inevitable, although its precise timing and origin remain uncertain.
This concern arises amidst a broader debate on Germany’s ‘debt brake,’ a constitutional policy limiting structural net borrowing to 0.35% of GDP. Reforming this fiscal rule has become an urgent issue, particularly in light of U.S. demands for Europe to increase its defense spending. Germany, obligated to allocate 2% of its GDP to NATO after 2027, must secure an additional €30 billion annually to sustain its military commitments. Though a special €100 billion fund was created in response to Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, most of those funds have already been allocated. Merz has indicated that while reforming the debt brake is not off the table, priority should be given to restructuring government expenditure, particularly in areas like refugee and unemployment benefits.
Merz’s economic stance has significant implications for Germany’s post-election coalition negotiations. His most viable partners—the center-left Social Democratic Party (SPD) and the Greens—have long argued that Germany’s fiscal constraints hinder necessary public investment. The potential ideological clash over debt policy may prove a major obstacle in forming a stable coalition.
Moreover, Merz’s economic-first approach has triggered tensions with the Greens, who have sought to integrate economic and climate policies. He has unequivocally stated that Economy Minister Robert Habeck’s policies, which merge economic and climate strategies, will not continue under his leadership. This divergence presents a significant hurdle for any potential CDU-Green coalition.
Further complicating the coalition landscape is Merz’s hardline stance on immigration. He has pledged to tighten Germany’s borders and take a stricter approach toward asylum seekers, aligning with the tougher migration policies adopted by other European leaders such as Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. These proposals directly conflict with the Greens’ stance and may instead push the CDU toward forming a coalition with the SPD, which has recently adopted a more rigid stance on illegal migration.
Key Reasons for Germany’s Economic Stagnation
Beyond fiscal and political challenges, Germany’s broader economic downturn is a growing concern. Once the powerhouse of Europe, the country has failed to achieve significant growth in the past five years. Several structural issues have contributed to this decline:
1. Deprived of Russian Energy
Germany’s economy has been heavily impacted by the loss of cheap Russian natural gas, a critical component of its industrial success. The decision to phase out nuclear power while increasing reliance on Russian gas created a vulnerable energy strategy. Following Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, gas supplies were cut, sending energy prices soaring.
While Germany has attempted to compensate by importing liquefied natural gas (LNG) from Qatar and the U.S., LNG remains significantly more expensive than pipeline gas. This has driven up costs for energy-intensive industries such as steel, chemicals, and glass manufacturing, reducing Germany’s competitiveness. Meanwhile, renewable energy expansion has been slow, hindered by infrastructure bottlenecks and local opposition to wind energy projects.
2. China’s Trade Takeover
For years, China served as a lucrative market for German exports, particularly in the automotive and industrial machinery sectors. However, China has since transitioned from being a key customer to a direct competitor. State subsidies have bolstered Chinese manufacturing, leading to a flood of cheap, high-quality goods in the global market, undercutting German industries.
The auto sector has been particularly affected. Once a dominant force, Germany’s automakers now face stiff competition from Chinese electric vehicle (EV) manufacturers. China’s vehicle exports surged from near zero in 2020 to 5 million in 2024, while Germany’s net exports were halved, reaching just 1.2 million.
3. Flailing Infrastructure
During the economic boom years, Germany maintained balanced budgets but neglected vital infrastructure investments. The effects of this neglect are now becoming painfully evident. Rail networks suffer from chronic delays and require urgent repairs. High-speed internet remains unavailable in many rural areas. Major energy transmission projects, such as the north-south power line, are years behind schedule, and key transport routes have faced closures due to structural issues, disrupting supply chains and mobility.
4. Shortage of Skilled Workers
Germany faces a severe shortage of skilled workers across multiple industries. A survey conducted by the German Chamber of Commerce and Industry found that nearly half of all companies cannot fill open positions. The problem is especially pronounced in STEM fields, where fewer German students are pursuing careers in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics.
An aging population further compounds the issue. Immigration policies have been slow to adapt, and bureaucratic hurdles make it difficult for high-skilled foreign workers to integrate into the labor force. A 2023 reform aimed at easing employment barriers for skilled immigrants has yet to yield significant results.
5. Consequences of Bureaucratic Red Tape
Germany’s business environment has been stifled by excessive bureaucracy and rigid regulations. Lengthy permit approval processes hinder investment in infrastructure projects, while redundant administrative requirements create inefficiencies. Businesses face unnecessary hurdles, from redundant supplier compliance certifications to outdated food safety record-keeping practices in the restaurant industry.
The Path Forward
As Germany navigates these mounting challenges, the next government will have to strike a delicate balance between fiscal prudence and necessary investments. Merz’s emphasis on economic growth as the key to resolving financial pressures highlights the need for structural reforms. However, whether his proposed measures—focusing on budget cuts and regulatory changes—will be sufficient to reignite Germany’s economic dynamism remains debatable.
A crucial decision looms regarding the debt brake. While fiscal conservatives argue that maintaining strict borrowing limits ensures long-term stability, proponents of reform believe that loosening these constraints is necessary for infrastructure development, digital transformation, and industrial competitiveness.
In addition, Germany must confront its changing position in the global economic hierarchy. The days of effortless dominance in manufacturing and exports are over, requiring a strategic pivot toward innovation-driven industries and new markets. The success of Germany’s transition will depend on its ability to reform bureaucratic inefficiencies, invest in human capital, and secure energy independence.
Germany stands at a crossroads. The outcome of its upcoming election and subsequent policy choices will shape not only its own economic future but also that of the broader European Union. With sovereign debt concerns looming, geopolitical pressures mounting, and economic stagnation deepening, decisive and pragmatic leadership is needed. Whether Friedrich Merz can navigate these complexities while maintaining political stability remains to be seen. What is clear, however, is that Germany can no longer afford complacency in an increasingly volatile global landscape.